Menu Close

Tag: 2016 News

WCIRB Says Industry Finally Reports 2015 Combined Loss Ratio Below 100%

The WCIRB has completed its report on statewide workers’ compensation insurer loss and premium experience through December 31, 2015. The major findings of the report include:

California written premium (gross of deductible credits) for 2015 is approximately $17.6 billion, which is approximately 7% above the written premium reported for 2014.

The projected industry average charged rate per $100 of payroll for policies incepting between July 1, 2015 and December 31, 2015 is $2.86, which is approximately 5% below the average rate charged for the first six months of 2015 and the first decrease in the average charged rate since 2009.

The WCIRB projects total ultimate losses and ALAE for accident year 2015 to be $13.1 billion, which is 5% above the projection for accident year 2014 and 34% above the projection for accident year 2009.

The WCIRB projects an ultimate accident year combined loss and expense ratio of 102% for 2015. Of this ratio, 60% is attributable to the indemnity and medical loss ratio and 42% is attributable to the loss adjustment and other expense ratio. This projection is consistent with the ratio for 2014 and below that of the prior several accident years.

The preliminary calendar year combined loss and expense ratio for 2015 reported by insurers is 99%, which is below the combined ratios for the last several years and is the first year since 2007 with a combined ratio below 100%.

The WCIRB projects indemnity claim frequency for accident year 2015 to be 1% below the frequency for 2014 but approximately 12% above the frequency for 2009. The frequency increases generally experienced over the last five years are largely attributed to increases in cumulative injury claims, late reported indemnity claims, claims involving injuries to multiple body parts, and claims from the Los Angeles area.

The WCIRB projects the average cost (or “severity”) of a 2015 indemnity claim to be approximately $85,000, which is approximately 3% higher than the projected severity for 2014 and approximately 6% higher than that for 2013.

Orange County Contractor Faces 49 Years in Comp Fraud Case

Five defendants were arraigned in Orange County for committing over $635,000 in tax and insurance fraud and failing to pay employees prevailing wage on public works contracts.

Babak Brian Abghari, 36, Newport Coast, Homayoun Harry Abghari, 57, Huntington Beach, Julio Roberto Alvarado, 47, San Pedro, Cody Lawson, 34, Long Beach, Phyllis Martinez, 51, Anaheim, are each charged with eight felony counts of taking and receiving a portion of a worker’s wage on a public work, 56 felony counts of recording a false or forged instrument, six felony counts of making a false statement to discourage an injured worker from claiming workers’ compensation benefits, and seven felony counts of willful failure to pay taxes, with sentencing enhancement allegations for property loss over $200,000.

Babak Aghari and Homayoun Aghari are also charged with three felony counts of misrepresenting facts to a workers’ compensation insurance company.

If convicted, the defendants face a maximum sentence of 49 years and six months in state prison. The defendants are scheduled for a pre-trial hearing on May 12, 2016, at 8:30 a.m. in Department C-55, Central Justice Center, Santa Ana.

Houmayoun Abghari and Babak Abghari are accused of owning and operating PCN3, a general contracting company that mainly conducts public works projects. Between Jan. 1, 2000, and March 30, 2015, the defendants are accused of fraudulently paying PCN3’s employees less than the prevailing wage in cash, and keeping the extra money owed to their employees. The defendants are accused of “shorting” the victims’ hours on certified payroll reports and/or requiring their victims’ to give cash back.

Martinez is accused of working as an office clerk at PCN3 and knowingly signing fraudulent certified payroll records under penalty of perjury.

Lawson is accused of working as a superintendent and Alvarado is accused of working as a foreman for PCN3 on public work’s projects. Lawson and Alvarado are accused of not paying employment taxes. Lawson and Alvarado are accused of giving paychecks or cash to victims for their work on the projects.

Houmayoun Abghari and Babak Abghari are accused of discouraging the victims from filing for workers’ compensation benefits after being injured on the work. Houmayoun Abghari and Babak Abghari are accused of knowingly filing false tax returns in which they understated the pay and amount of hours that their employees received.

One of the victims contacted the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, who notified the Orange County District Attorney’s Office (OCDA). The OCDA and the Department of Industrial Relations and Labor Commissioners Office investigated this case.

Deputy District Attorney Donde McCament of the Insurance Fraud Unit is prosecuting this case.

CWCI Analysis of Recent Payment Data Shows Mixed Results

The Claims Journal reports that a new analysis of the average California workers’ comp medical loss, indemnity benefit and medical cost containment (MCC) payments on accident year (AY) 2005 through 2014 lost-time claims valued through June 2015 reveal mixed results, with more developed data on older claims showing paid medical losses and indemnity leveling out or declining, while less developed data on newer claims indicating that average amounts paid in the early stages of a claim are on the rise.

The California Workers’ Compensation Institute reviewed data from 1.8 million lost-time claims for work injuries that occurred during the 10-year span ending in December 2014, the study’s authors calculated the average amounts paid per claim for medical services and indemnity benefits at 6, 12, 24, 36, 48 and 60 months post injury, with results broken out by accident year.

Prior studies found that after a brief post-reform decline in AY 2005, average medical loss payments, which include payments for medical treatment, drugs and durable medical equipment (DME), and medical-legal services, but not medical cost containment, began a steady uptrend starting in AY 2006.

The updated figures show similar results, but recent growth patterns for paid medical losses varied depending on when the payments were valued. For example, first-year medical losses increased steadily from AY 2005 through AY 2010, declined briefly in AY 2011 then began to trend up again, edging up 0.8 percent in AY 2012, before increasing 2.8 percent in 2013 and 6.2 percent in 2014.

In contrast, more mature data on older claims showed steady growth until recently, but the latest results indicate slight reductions in paid medical losses at 24, 36 and 48 months post injury, the first declines in several years. The most developed data in the study tracks average amounts paid at 60 months post injury, so data on claims from AY 2010 is the most recent available, and these results show the average medical loss per claim at five years of development rose 2.7 percent in AY 2010 compared to AY 2009, though that was significantly less than the double-digit increases noted in each of the four prior years. Paid medical loss trends at all six levels of development for claims from AY 2005 through the most recent year for which data are available are noted in the chart.

In addition to tracking paid medical losses over the past decade, the study measures changes in average payments for medical treatment (physician and non-physician fees, lab and pathology charges, hospitals and ambulatory surgery center fees, transportation, etc.); drugs and DME; med-legal services; MCC (which is a loss adjustment expense), and indemnity benefits, which include temporary disability, permanent disability, supplemental job displacement benefits, life pensions and death benefits. As with the medical loss results, average payments for each category were calculated at six levels of development for indemnity claims from AY 2005 through AY 2014. Tables with results for all claims, including medical-only cases, are included as appendices to the report.

CWCI has published its study in a Research Update report, “California Workers’ Compensation Claims Monitoring: Medical & Indemnity Development, AY 2005 – AY 2014.” The public can access the report at www.cwci.org/research.html.

Wearable Technology for Comp Injuries Presented at RIMS Annual Conference

When a paralyzed mother crossed the finish line of the 26.2-mile London Marathon in a bionic suit, it marked a watershed moment for wearable technology; the exoskeleton had arrived.

The recent FDA approval of the exoskeleton, which enables paraplegics, amputees and people with muscle or nerve damage to walk, is the latest milestone in the new world of wearable technology for injured workers, according to Zack Craft, ATP, Vice President of Rehab Solutions and Complex Care Education at One Call Care Management (“One Call”).

Craft spoke on wearable technology and workers’ compensation at the RIMS 2016 Annual Conference held April 10 – 13 in San Diego, California, along with Felicia Amenta, Workers’ Compensation Program Manager for San Diego County and Imperial Schools. Their presentation, “The New Game Changer in Managing Worksite Health: Wearable Technology,” introduced attendees to ways in which wearable technology can benefit injured workers, their employers and payers.

Speaking about the exoskeleton, Craft noted: “For an employee with catastrophic injuries, the exoskeleton holds enormous potential to give them back a part of their lives they thought was lost forever.”

Other types of wearable technology that are applicable in the workplace range from postural devices to activity trackers to GPS locators. Benefits of these devices include wellness, prevention of injuries, increased productivity, compliance with treatment regimes to prevent injury and avoid re-injury, and enhanced independence and quality of life.

As wearable technologies are introduced into the workplace, and especially for the treatment of injured workers, specialists such as assistive technology experts can advise claims managers on which technologies may be most appropriate, taking into consideration the long-term view of the injury, the home environment, and patients’ needs for functionality and independence.

Assistive technology is an umbrella term that includes assistive, adaptive, and rehabilitative devices for people with disabilities and also includes the process used in selecting, locating, and using them. Assistive technology promotes greater independence by enabling people to perform tasks that they were formerly unable to accomplish, or had great difficulty accomplishing, by providing enhancements to, or changing methods of interacting with, the technology needed to accomplish such tasks.

RESNA, the Rehabilitation Engineering and Assistive Technology Society of North America, advances the field by offering certification, continuing education, and professional development; developing assistive technology standards; promoting research and public policy; and sponsoring forums for the exchange of information and ideas to meet the needs of our multidisciplinary constituency. RESNA certified assistive technology experts can be located nationwide by using the search tool on the RESNA website.

California State University in Northridge, Center on Disabilities just finished its 31st Annual International Technology and Persons with Disabilities Conference last month in San Diego. For over 30 years, the Annual International Technology and Persons with Disabilities Conference, has provided an inclusive setting for researchers, practitioners, exhibitors, end users, speakers and other participants to share knowledge and best practices in the field of assistive technology. In 2015, the conference drew more than 4,800 people to San Diego. The annual conference is a forum that showcases cutting edge technology and practical solutions.The conference is the largest of its kind in the world. The 32nd Annual CSUN Conference is scheduled for February 27 to March 4, 2017 at the Manchester Grand Hyatt Hotel in San Diego.

CSUN also just launched two new master’s degrees in assistive technology. It says that assistive technology is “one of the fastest-growing segments of the rapidly expanding health and human services field.”

Insurance Agent Convicted of Felony Insurance Fraud

Kannai David Scantlen, 41, of Valley Springs, a former insurance agent conducting business as Kan I Save Insurance Services, was convicted of insurance fraud and sentenced to 60 days, three years formal probation, and ordered to pay $20,000 restitution.

A joint investigation by the California Department of Insurance Investigation Division and the Amador County Workers’ Compensation Fraud Unit revealed Scantlen received premiums from business owners to purchase general liability and workers’ compensation coverage for their businesses but failed to forward the money to the insurer. Scantlen pocketed approximately $20,000 from six clients, mostly contractors, leaving the businesses and their employees with no liability or workers’ compensation coverage.

“Scantlen put legitimate business owners at great financial risk when he stole their premium payments and left them without workers’ compensation coverage,” said Insurance Commissioner Dave Jones. “If an agent or broker provides you with an insurance certificate, it is important to follow up with the insurance company and to verify your coverage and make sure you receive an actual policy.”

Scantlen provided his clients with fraudulent insurance certificates showing they had valid coverage, but the policy information on the certificates was bogus. The companies listed on the certificates confirmed they had no record of receiving premium and had no record of coverage for the businesses.

The Department of Insurance is concerned that there are more victims that may believe they have insurance and do not have coverage. Anyone who purchased insurance coverage from Scantlen between 2012 and 2015, and received an insurance certificate should make sure they have an actual copy of a policy or contact their insurer and verify coverage and contact the department at 800-927-4357 to report any suspicions or concerns.

Scantlen was sentenced April 6, 2016 and has so far reimbursed $11,000 to his victims. The department is taking action to revoke his license. Scantlen’s agent license is currently suspended.

WCAB Chairwoman Ronnie Caplane to Retire and Move to Zenith as VP

Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board Chairwoman Ronnie Caplane is retiring from state service at the end of April. She was appointed commissioner in 2003 by Governor Gray Davis, reappointed in 2009 by Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger, and appointed Chairwoman by Governor Jerry Brown in 2011.

During her tenure on the Appeals Board, the California workers’ compensation laws underwent two major reforms. The first came with SB 899 in 2004; later, as Chairwoman, she presided over the first judicial body to review cases that fell under SB 863’s landmark 2013 reforms.

“Ronnie Caplane managed WCAB through significant legislative changes, and has made valuable contributions to improving the workers’ compensation system,” said DIR Director Christine Baker.

Commissioner Caplane was admitted to the State Bar in 1975 after graduating from the University of Wisconsin, Madison and UC Hastings College of Law. She was an associate attorney for Lewis, Rouda and Lewis from 1976 to 1978 and then a trial attorney for the U.S. Department of Justice’s Civil Division from 1979 to 1982. Caplane was also a partner with Bruyneel and Caplane from 1983 to 1985, and a freelance writer and columnist for East Bay area publications the Piedmonter and the Montclarion from 1992 to 2006. She has published essays in newspapers throughout the country including the San Francisco Chronicle, the Cleveland Plain Dealer, the Chicago Tribune, the Detroit Free Press, the Recorder, Legal Times, and various Jewish publications. Her essays have also appeared in several anthologies.

She has also served as a member and President of the Piedmont School Board. Her leadership in education and work to improve the East Bay community led Assemblywoman Wilma Chan to name her Woman of the Year in 2004. Her commitment to public education and to restore California to its status as a national leader led Caplane to pursue a run for the California Assembly.

In 2006, she made an unsuccessful run for a seat in the Assembly, coming in third with 12.5 percent of the vote in a five-way Democratic primary won by Assembly Member Sandré Swanson.

Commissioner Caplane suffered the tragic loss of her husband Joe Remcho – a prominent Bay Area lawyer and influential adviser to many of California’s most powerful politicians – in January 2003 as a result of a helicopter crash in the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta while he was the solo pilot of the craft. At the time of his death he was a partner in the San Leandro law firm of Remcho, Johansen & Purcell. For two decades, the firm has represented the state Legislature in redistricting matters and other cases involving voter initiatives, term limits and campaign finance. Remcho’s clients included Gov. Gray Davis, Attorney General Lockyer, Sen. Dianne Feinstein and Mayor Willie Brown, the former state Assembly speaker. After his death she wrote a series of “grief columns” that drew an overwhelming response from readers.

Commissioner Caplane volunteered thousands of hours for a myriad of community organizations including Oakland’s Temple Sinai, HEROS, the Henry Robinson Center and the Piedmont schools. She created a minority law school scholarship through the Bar Association of San Francisco in her husband’s honor.

Following retirement, she will be joining Zenith Insurance Company as a Vice President.

DWC Proposes More Time to Claim Supplemental Payments

The Return-to-Work Supplement Program is one of the components of Senate Bill 863. Labor Code section 139.48 requires the Director to administer a $120 million fund for the purpose of making supplemental payments to workers whose permanent disability benefits are disproportionately low in comparison to their earnings losses. The program is based on studies conducted by RAND regarding permanent disability; specifically “Identifying Permanently Disabled Workers with Disproportionate Earnings Losses for Supplemental Payments.” (February 2014)

Section 17304 of the regulations provides that an application for the Return-to-Work Supplement must be received by the Return-to-Work Supplement Program within one year from the date the Voucher was served on the individual or within one year from the effective date of the regulations, whichever is later.

The Department of Industrial Relations has received and posted a petition from the California Applicants’ Attorneys Association (CAAA) proposing modifications to the California Code of Regulations for the Return-to-Work Supplement Program. This petition is made by CAAA pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act sections 11340.6 and 11340.7.

In the Petition CAAA voices concern that the “regulations implemented for the Return-to-Work Supplement Program became effective April 13, 2015. Therefore, injured workers who received a voucher on or before April 13, 2015, will no longer be able to apply after April 13, 2016. This is although these individuals did not receive notice of their eligibility to apply for the program when they received their voucher. In fact, the Supplemental Job Displacement Voucher form was not updated with a notice of eligibility for the Return-to-Work Supplement Program until December 1, 2015.”

CAAA believes that the low number of applicants to the Return-to-Work Supplement program in 2015 (less than 12,000 when at least 24,000 were projected by the Rand study commissioned by CHSWC) is most likely due to this lack of notice of eligibility, as well as some difficulties in using the online application process.

The proposed changes to 8 CCR section 17304 will correct it to read “An application for the Return-to-Work Supplement must be received by the Return-to-Work Supplement Program within one year from the date the updated Voucher form containing notice was served on the individual, or one year from the effective date of this amendment to the regulations for those individuals who received vouchers before December 1, 2015.”.

CAAA proposed and supports this amendment to section 17304 as a fair remedy to allow all eligible injured workers the opportunity to apply for the Return-to-Work Supplement payment.

A public hearing on the modifications proposed by CAAA’s petition has been scheduled at 10 a.m. on Friday, April 15, 2016, in Room 7, second floor, 1515 Clay Street in Oakland. Members of the public may also submit written comments on the regulations to Nathan Schmidt, Counsel, Office of the Director, Legal Unit, P.O. Box 420603, San Francisco, CA 94142-0603 until 5 p.m. on April 15, 2016.

The CAAA RTW Petition and Notice of Public Hearing on Petition to Amend Regulations can be found on the DIR website.

Convicted Napa Doctor Allowed to Practice After Release from Prison

A Napa doctor has agreed this month to pay the U.S. government $400,000 to settle allegations that he filed false claims for Medicare reimbursement,. The agreement with Ali Vaziri, M.D., a gastroenterologist, settles the civil allegations but it provides that , while agreeing to pay the $400,000, Vaziri does not admit to any liability. Vaziri is a board-certified gastroenterologist with a practice called the “Center For Digestive & Liver” in Napa.

Federal attorneys said that between 2007 and 2011, Vaziri billed Medicare for patient office visits that were longer and included more services than the consultations he actually provided. He was also alleged to have billed separately for office visits that were required to be billed together with colonoscopies.

Vaziri, a 1990 graduate of the Tufts University School of Medicine, has faced a number of legal challenges in recent years.

In June 2015, the Medical Board of California placed Vaziri on seven years’ probation and prohibited him from supervising physician assistants because of a criminal conviction for tax fraud.

In June 2014, Vaziri was sentenced to a year and a day in federal prison for tax fraud after cheating the IRS of more than $116,700, according to federal prosecutors. Vaziri, who was indicted in 2012, served his sentence at a federal facility in Lompoc, said his attorney, Malcolm Segal of Sacramento, in a 2015 interview.

The physician was sentenced under a plea agreement reached in early 2014, when he agreed to plead guilty to four counts of filing false income tax returns between 2005 and 2008. The charges were filed in connection with income and expenses from his medical practice. In 2005, Vaziri falsely inflated his business expenses, causing the IRS to lose $14,535 in taxes and then repeated the fraud for the next three years, underpaying $60,620 in 2006, $27,476 in 2007 and $14,072 in 2008, according to U.S. Attorney Melinda Haag.

In exchange for his guilty plea, entered in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, federal officials dropped health care fraud allegations.

Vaziri attracted the attention of federal officials beginning in June 2009 when he was suspected of overbilling and falsely billing Medicare, according to a sentencing memorandum filed by prosecutors. As the investigation progressed, federal investigators delved into potential income tax fraud. In June, 2012 he was was charged by a federal grand jury in San Francisco with nine counts of health care fraud and six counts of filing a false federal income tax return.

“Dr. Vaziri will be fully permitted to practice medicine. Any restrictions will not impede his ability to practice,” said Segal according to the 2015 report in the Napa Valley Register.

Claim Adjusters Charged For Embezzling $250K From Carrier

Elizabeth Louise Brown, 48, of Canyon Country, a former claims adjuster with Explorer Insurance, was arrested and charged with multiple felonies, including insurance fraud and conspiracy for allegedly embezzling more than $276,000 from her employer. Another eight were also arrested and charged with fraud. Additional arrests are expected as the investigation continues.

According to Department of Insurance detectives, between January 2013 and September 2015, while employed by Explorer Insurance as a claims adjuster, Brown allegedly embezzled from the company by adding friends and family members to claims, which resulted in the insurer issuing fraudulent payments to Brown’s co-conspirators.

Evidence of Brown’s alleged crimes were discovered by Explorer Insurance when they identified fraudulent checks issued in 87 claims assigned to her. Explorer terminated Brown’s employment and, as required by law, reported the suspected crimes to the department, which launched a criminal investigation. The investigation into how Brown profited from the scheme is ongoing. This case is being prosecuted by the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office Auto Insurance Fraud Division.

“Brown’s alleged crimes are unconscionable,” said Insurance Commissioner Dave Jones. “Every one of us pays for fraud through higher premiums when insurers pass their losses along to consumers. Our work with the district attorney and Explorer Insurance helped solve this crime.”

DWC Admits Many of Largest Lien Claimants are Currently Criminally Indicted

The Center for Investigative Reporting is a nonprofit news organization based in Emeryville, California, and has conducted investigative journalism since 1977. It is known for producing stories that reveal scandals or corruption in government agencies and corporations. In 2010, CIR launched its California Watch reporting project. Its current investigatory effort exposes fraud in California’s workers’ compensation system. An analysis of more than a million court cases details how workers have been swept into medical billing mills, prescribed unregulated medications and advised to undergo sometimes unneeded or high-risk surgery by doctors who were raking in bribes. The CIR report has now birthed follow up articles in many California leading publications.

The Sacramento Bee in a series of related articles points out that a review of thousands of criminal court records by The Center for Investigative Reporting shows a system in which pay-to-play schemes trump patient care, particularly in unregulated treatments rejected by insurers and “disputed in obscure courts throughout the state.” Prosecutors are pursuing charges against more than 80 medical professionals who’ve handled more than 100,000 injured-worker cases, most of them originating in Southern California. They allege that the cases account for $1 billion in fraud.

And the Sacramento Bee story suggests that “nobody cares about policing health care for injured workers.” Thousands of unregulated medical providers can spurn legislated checks and balances on medical care in the only-in-California network of 24 workers’ compensation courts. Anyone can demand money – a process known as filing a medical lien – for unregulated medical treatments that include the use of questionable devices, pain creams, shockwave therapies and DNA tests. And in an overburdened system that favors settlements over trials, they often succeed”.

“We know there’s a problem,” said Christine Baker, director of the state Department of Industrial Relations, which administers workers’ compensation. Baker’s agency worked with lawmakers on a 2012 law that was meant to limit the filing of medical liens. It established a $150 fee required to demand payment in workers’ compensation courts. It also gave insurers new powers to deny money to providers that aren’t approved to treat injured workers.

Yet claims for unapproved care still are cropping up, Baker said. And the number of liens filed last year is even higher than it was when one of Baker’s advisers initially concluded that the system “rewards bad behavior.” Baker said her department has begun reviewing the medical providers who currently file the largest number of liens. The result: “We do note that many are (criminally) indicted.”

“We’re talking about a patient that has become a commodity,” said Don Marshall, chairman of the state’s Fraud Assessment Commission, which distributes funds to prosecutors who fight workers’ compensation fraud. “It’s become something to trade and sell on the open market for no other reason than to generate income.”

Workers who’ve been hurt on the job often are the last to find out that they have been exploited – if they find out at all.