Ruben Gonzalez had been head coach of Cerritos College’s women’s soccer team since 2006 and also taught health, sports psychology, and other classes. In January 2021, the Board of Trustees of the Cerritos Community College District voted to dismiss him under Education Code § 87732, which lists the grounds for dismissing a permanent community college employee. The district’s amended charges accused him of immoral conduct, dishonesty, evident unfitness for service, and persistent violation of school laws or regulations.
An administrative law judge (ALJ) held an 11-day hearing beginning in September 2021. Because many allegations reached back more than a decade, Gonzalez invoked the four-year limit in Education Code § 87680, and the ALJ excluded most evidence older than four years. The ALJ did admit part of the testimony of former player CR, who said that after she reported sexual misconduct to the athletic dean in 2013, Gonzalez angrily confronted her in front of the team, cut her playing time, and gave her a negative reference when she tried to transfer.
Two more recent players also testified. AZ said that after a 2019 investigation, Gonzalez told players not to speak to investigators and dismissed the allegations, that the team environment was toxic, and that he did nothing after a teammate threatened her for reporting misconduct. AJ described a road trip on which coaches were intoxicated while Gonzalez was present, flirtation during practice, and a chat-app accusation that a player was sleeping with a coach; she said she did not report an assault by an assistant coach for fear of losing playing time. Several defense witnesses testified that Gonzalez never discouraged reporting, and Gonzalez denied wrongdoing.
In August 2022, the ALJ upheld the dismissal on two grounds, immoral conduct and evident unfitness for service, finding the three players credible and Gonzalez not credible about how he treated CR after her report. The ALJ rejected the dishonesty and persistent-violation charges.
Both sides petitioned the Los Angeles County Superior Court for a writ of administrative mandamus under Code of Civil Procedure § 1094.5: Gonzalez to overturn the dismissal, and the district to challenge the evidentiary exclusions and the dishonesty ruling. Exercising its independent judgment as required by Education Code § 87682, Judge James C. Chalfant denied both petitions in November 2024. The court agreed that the ALJ properly excluded most time-barred evidence and properly found evident unfitness for service, but it reversed the immoral-conduct finding, concluding that Gonzalez’s failure to address the teammate’s threat against AZ was not immoral conduct. Gonzalez appealed.
In the partially published case of Gonzalez v. Board of Trustees of the Cerritos Community College District, No. B344342 (November 2026), the Second District Court of Appeal, Division Two, affirmed the trial court’s judgment denying Gonzalez’s petition, leaving his dismissal for evident unfitness for service in place. The opinion was filed November 6, 2026, and modified and certified for partial publication on November 18, 2026; Parts II and IV of the Discussion are not published.
Because the trial court exercised its independent judgment, the Court of Appeal asked only whether substantial evidence supported the trial court’s findings. It did not reweigh the evidence or second-guess credibility determinations.
The court explained that “evident unfitness for service” means being clearly unsuited for the position, ordinarily because of a defect in temperament. Courts first apply the factors set out in Morrison v. State Board of Education (1969) 1 Cal.3d 214 to determine whether the conduct bears on fitness to teach, and then ask whether the unfitness is “evident,” meaning attributable to a temperamental defect. Only the relevant Morrison factors need be addressed, and the court found that the trial court had properly considered them.
Substantial evidence showed that Gonzalez knew of the toxic team environment. The court pointed to his instruction that players avoid investigators, his role in an earlier agreement to keep an assistant coach “in check,” his presence when coaches were intoxicated, his awareness of flirtation and the chat-app allegation, and his failure to act after the teammate’s threat against AZ. He knew of multiple investigations, tried to shut down two of them, and on two occasions reacted with anger toward players who reported misconduct. Given the team culture, the court held, that was enough to support a finding that players were discouraged from reporting, and the trial court was entitled to reject the contrary defense testimony. The court also found no meaningful inconsistency in the trial court’s statements about what Gonzalez knew.
On the four-year limit in section 87680, the court relied on Atwater Elementary School Dist. v. California Dept. of General Services (2007) 41 Cal.4th 227, which recognized that equitable estoppel can permit evidence outside the four-year window. CR’s testimony about retaliation after her report was properly admitted, because the retaliation was itself recent misconduct and she had been prevented from reporting it. In any event, the court concluded that the testimony of AZ and AJ alone supported the finding, so Gonzalez could not show prejudice or a miscarriage of justice.
In an unpublished part of the opinion, the court declined to consider Gonzalez’s argument that he was owed back pay for his unpaid suspension now that the immoral-conduct charge supporting it had been reversed. The court held the argument was forfeited because he had not properly raised it below.